Ok, I'll present the evidence for it and against it...


For It:

Windhover's fed Alazare in the prologue in book 2. Alazare had ringing in his head, could have easily made him go blind...also, Valzaan's been around for a LONG time...and he was reborn 3 times, the first time could have been on the Holy Mountain...and finally, because L.B. likes to foreshadow events before they actually happen (like with Synoki being Malek, Joriam's death, etc...)

Against It:

Joriaem's never seemed to fullfill the prophecy he had on the forbidden isle or wherever about Balimere the Beautiful...(maybe he's alazare and has memmory loss?...that'd be a hilarious twist...the last titan who has alzhiemers...hahahahaha...but probably not...:p

It'd be to obvious (but this hasn't stopped L.B. in the past, so...)

Now vote just yes or no to the question...or add more evidence one way or the other...

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
So, the BotB administrator has been more than co-operative with me and others now, so i retract what i had on my sig, but leave the picture because i, well, think it looks pretty cool...

oh, and you can still check out hot topics and debates here: [z4.invisionfree.com]

thank you,

CalvinandHobbes

wow calvin nice question, but i dont want to eat my words so ill just sit on the fence

wow! I never thought of that! but i guess it's not impossible...

-------------------------------------------
"There are two types of people in the world: Those who say to God 'thy will be done', and those to whom God says 'all right then, have it your way'"
--C.S. Lewis

I dunno. I think it's equal either way. I won't be suprised, whatever happens - I just want it to hurry up and happen!!

Pay no attention to the bird behind the curtain!!
Trav is a SHE
http://www.musings-in-a-strange-land.blogspot.com/
I am a Wraith of Yore...fear me and my power of forgotten-thread blackmail

Hmm.... it's an interesting theory. However, I'm not entirely sure about it.




A writer is somebody for whom writing is more difficult than it is for other people- Thomas Mann




My writing blog: [aspiringpen.blogspot.com]

anyway, this is one of the things I am least certain about. I tend to lean towards the "no", but I really am right on the fence. I just don't know.

Finally, brothers,
whatever is true,
whatever is honorable,
whatever is just,
whatever is pure,
whatever is lovely,
whatever is commendable,
if there is any excellence,
if there is anything worthy of praise,
think about these things.
Philippians 4:8

Lol, I think no one's really sure. I think I lean more toward the "yes," though...

The Traveler Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I dunno. I think it's equal either way. I won't be
> suprised, whatever happens - I just want it to
> hurry up and happen!!

SAME HERE! But... He didn't recognize that Synoki was Malak, so I'm leaning towards no.





President and Founder of Twilight is Overrated Club
The Traveler as Vice President
Current Members: Galadriel, Trav,Eberwolf, Aljeron12, Sulmandir, vareth in silico
Purl, LovelornLark, Mindarin, Anna-Light Warrior, Caeli

There are three rules of writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
— W. Somerset Maugham

synkok is malek???

have you read the 4th book?

I'm leaning toward the 'yes' because Valzaan's past really wasn't ever dished out. But I'm hoping not.

___
Signatures are annoying, I refuse to have one.